Home › Forums › Breakaway Professional Products – [discontinued] › Preprocessing
- This topic has 33 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 15 years, 6 months ago by Leif.
-
AuthorPosts
-
May 17, 2009 at 3:08 am #7254LeifKeymaster
Guillou, I’m sorry but you misunderstood completely — I’m not trying to clone Orban’s sound.
Also, looking at that block diagram, the guy is on the wrong track 😉.
///Leif
May 17, 2009 at 5:08 am #7255AnonymousGuest[quote author=”Guillou”]Maybe this can help you because someone try to clone the orban’s sound…
http://www.soundprocessing.nl/settings.html[/quote]
That looks like the work of Christofer Bustad. I had high hopes for his "Energize" processing plugin, but I could never get it to sound just right… either it was too aggressive, or barely doing anything:http://www.bustad.com/energize/index.html
And as for using pre-processing ahead of Breakaway, that just seems backwards to me. I used to use Sound Solution as pre-processing ahead of a CRL AM Stereo Matrix Processor. With lots of tweaking I could get SS to serve well as an AGC and multiband compressor, but it had terrible clipping and no provisions for AM broadcast limiting/filtering, so I left that part to the CRL box.
Here’s a little sample I made back in January 2004 of that setup, transmitting in Harris AM Stereo (now an obsolete system, as C-QUAM became the standard) and received on a multi-system Sony AM Stereo receiver:
http://mysite.verizon.net/tekel/harris.mp3Someday I’ll make a similar test recording, just using the output of Breakway right into my Panasonic multi-system AM Stereo generator. Name the system you want: Magnavox, Kahn, Harris, or Motorola C-QUAM. 🙂
May 17, 2009 at 6:32 am #7256JesseGMemberHonestly… Breakaway can get way more similar to the sound of an Orban, than those plugins ever will. Not to mention you can BUY an actual Orban for the price of all the extreme rip-off price those Waves plugins are.
May 17, 2009 at 6:47 am #7257LeifKeymasterNo Shit!
I know that guy (Christopher Bustad). He was sitting in at a meeting at Swedish Radio when I was there last month, as an MPEG expert! Small world 😉.
Best,
///LeifMay 18, 2009 at 1:43 am #7258JesseGMemberHey Kevin, long time no see… since your Radio-Info days… before you left because of the encroaching stupidity of the HD AM talking heads, among other things I’m sure… the least of the rest of what screwed up stuff happened over there, but thats a whole other thread. 😉
I like the SS and CRL sample. Not bad at all. Does that do asymmetrical limiting/clipping?
Here’s Breakaway running a preset that combines Plutonium and Rusticity… Rustonium, and I tweaked it a little to sound pretty darn OK on NRSC AM-Stereo.
http://ictybtihky.com/bafm/sbt%20wowy%2 … 2075uS.mp3
This is with 10kHz low-pass, 30Hz high-pass, and 50% positive asymmetry. And it’s pretty darn loud I might add. Not bad eh?screenshots of the de-emphasized WAV
http://img507.imageshack.us/img507/536/ … wowynr.png
http://img507.imageshack.us/img507/1994 … wowynr.pngHere’s the FM version, for a comparison.
http://ictybtihky.com/bafm/sbt%20wowy%20FM%2075uS.mp3May 18, 2009 at 7:16 pm #7259AnonymousGuest[quote author=”JesseG”]I like the SS and CRL sample. Not bad at all. Does that do asymmetrical limiting/clipping?[/quote]
Yes, I have the CRL set to do +125% / -100% modulation, measured and tweaked with an oscilloscope. 🙂May 19, 2009 at 9:10 pm #7260AnonymousGuestHere is a recording of my chain. Run a lot of styles thru it, it’s a big file (152 mb)
http://www.stoeredj.nl/bbp/compellor_orban1100_bbp.flac
I know it’s a bit ‘dirty’ and some things are not passing 100% right, i still have to finetune some things but it’s coming really close to what i like. And, in the end, i don’t like a totally clean sound 🙂
Like to hear your comments (especially Leif of course 🙂)
May 20, 2009 at 1:50 am #7261LeifKeymasterHey Kingniels,
Sorry to disappoint.. If you’re looking for smashed audio without distortion, then you have succeeded — it’s "clean" — but you won’t catch me listening for more than a couple of minutes. 🙂
I hear the multiband compressor in the 1100 going nuts in the R&B tracks starting at 13:00 — the bottom of the voice falls out every time the kick hits, causing extreme spectral gain intermodulation. The voice thickens and thins in reverse sync with the drums — I absolutely cannot stand this error, and none of my processors have ever done this — not even the original OctiMax! Orban processors do this because of how their multiband stage is designed, and it cannot be tweaked around other than by making it so slow that it does nothing at all.
Other than that.. Smashed, smashed, smashed. No hint of dynamics. It does have the "Orban-sound" to it. It used to be that you HAD to make the audio sound like this, in order to be loud. It was a side effect. I can see recreating the sound for nostalgic reasons, but to actually listen to it? Count me out.
Best,
///LeifMay 20, 2009 at 10:20 am #7262AnonymousGuestHi Leif,
I was expecting an answer like this! Haha 😉
I know it’s smashed, but all hit/CHR stations in Holland are sounding like this. It’s not a sound to listen to with headphones, but in a car or at home on a hifi system i think it works very well..
That R&B song is a difficult one, thats why i put ‘m in the recording. That voice/kick thing is something i can live with, but i don’t like how the kick is smashing against the limiters/clipper.
Maybe i have to decrease the multiband drive in the orban and/or in Breakaway. I’m really looking forward to tweak with this setup with the more advanced version of Breakaway, because BBP is now setup for full processing (AGC to clipper), so i have to deal with that in the settings on the Orban.
Have you heard QMusic when you was in Holland? If not, i will make a recording of them, they are going crazy on multiband and clipping 🙂
May 20, 2009 at 11:17 am #7263LeifKeymasterWhoa, multiband in Breakaway? What?? 🙂
Dude, if you’re running an 1100 in front, you need to be running the Protection Clip preset, and not use any compression in BBP at all! Likewise, turn "Final Limiter Drive" (or whatever it’s called in the 1100) all the way down, so that the 1100 doesn’t do any limiting. Split the workload, don’t double it!
Some compression, to remove long-term dynamics, certainly helps a lot with smaller speakers and/or noisy environments.
However, removing short-term dynamics (i.e. smashing the audio), contrary to popular belief among audio processing enthusiast, does not come through better in any speaker or environment! Short term dynamics contain the "punch" of the audio, and no speaker, big or small, will recreate it once lost.You’re right, that song is a good torture test cut.
///Leif
May 22, 2009 at 11:54 am #7264AnonymousGuestI know that if i want to do it ‘technically correct’ i have to use the protection preset only. But then i miss something, thats why is choose to have a little bit of additional multiband. The high end gets more open..
Maybe i have lower some things to make it better to listen to. But remember that i use this processing only for myself to listen to 🙂. Also i’m working as imaging producer at a national radio station, and i use this setup to test how things sound thru processing (my sound is an ’emulation’ of the station’s sound, witch runs a 8400).
May 24, 2009 at 8:09 pm #7265Lee XSMemberKingdaniels,
You may be pleased to know that I am working on a preset for this kind of "Top 40" sound for BBP but hopefully without the side effects, as Leif mentioned.
I agree with both your comments and Leifs, there is a big demand for this flavor with the HIT/CHR stations, it seems to be the type of sound that they want. But weather or not this type of sound is preferred because people actually like it or because people are just following every else’s sound because that’s what they are used to, is another story altogether. It’s not my personal favorite type of sound, (it used to be!) but I’m designing a preset with this sound in mind. I’ve got stations here in London busting my balls for it…..I’ve not had enough time on it yet…but I’ll upload some clips soon for some feedback.
P.S, don’t get too excited also, because it’s up to the main man Leif and the other guys to decide if it will ever go into the BBP package.Also, Kingdaniels, I’d strongly recommend running BBP in 6db clip mode with your setup also. 😉
May 25, 2009 at 1:30 pm #7266AnonymousGuestmodman,
A preset like that would be nice! Looking forward to hear some examples!
6db clip mode: Then i’m missing some bass/high ‘effects’, it sounds a bit empty. Of course thats because the Orban is for HD radio, not for FM so it’s very clean. Thats why i used (in this case) the Plutonium preset with a little but (maybe too much for your taste 😀) multiband processing. The Amsterdam preset is also working very well.
If i had full control, i made a setting between 6 db clip and amsterdam 🙂 No AGC and the high/low ends of the Amsterdam preset, with not to much going on.
May 25, 2009 at 2:40 pm #7267AppieMember[quote author=”Appie”]Next week i try an Behringer composer in front of BBP ..
BBP works fine standalone leiff 😉
Its only to see what is happening , because a lot of stations use preprocessing to get more punch .[/quote]
Update :
I try the setup with a composer in front ..
It doesnt sound better , even worser
For those who wanna try DONT , use BBP standalone !
May 25, 2009 at 3:52 pm #7268LeifKeymasterI couldn’t agree more.
To my ears, Punch equals Dynamics. Punch does not equal lack of dynamics. Chaining processors gives you a lack of dynamics. How much simpler can an equation get? 🙂
///Leif
-
AuthorPosts
- The forum ‘Breakaway Professional Products – [discontinued]’ is closed to new topics and replies.